Certainly! Here's an updated list of restaurants that are open and serving up delicious meals on Sanibel Island as of August 2024, following the impacts of Hurricane Ian:
Hello, fellow food enthusiasts! Sanibel Island has always been a culinary gem, offering a unique blend of fresh seafood and island-inspired dishes. While Hurricane Ian left its mark, the island's resilient community and dedicated restaurateurs have brought back some beloved spots while also introducing new ones. Here’s a look at the must-try restaurants that are open and serving up fantastic cuisine as of August 2024.
MudBugs Cajun Kitchen
MudBugs Cajun Kitchen has returned with its signature Southern and Cajun dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for jambalaya, shrimp po'boys, or fried alligator, this place delivers bold flavors with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The new location features an outdoor seating area perfect for enjoying those island breezes.
Grandma Dots
First opened back up as a food truck after the Hurricane, it's back and better than ever! Nestled within the picturesque Sanibel Marina, Gramma Dot’s Restaurant is a beloved island treasure that has been serving up fresh, flavorful seafood and classic American dishes for years. One of the highlights of dining at Gramma Dot’s is the opportunity to enjoy your meal while watching boats come and go from the marina, creating a serene and quintessentially Floridian backdrop.
Jerry’s Restaurant
Located within Jerry’s Foods, this restaurant has been a staple for years and remains a favorite for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re stopping by for a hearty breakfast, a light lunch, or dinner, Jerry’s offers comfort food done right. Their pancakes, burgers, and fresh seafood dishes are simple yet satisfying.
The Sanibel Grill
A sister establishment to The Timbers, The Sanibel Grill has reopened and is serving up its popular pub fare. With a focus on fresh seafood, burgers, and sandwiches, it’s the perfect spot for a casual meal. The lively atmosphere and sports bar vibe make it a great place to catch a game while enjoying good food and drinks.
Island Pizza
Island Pizza is a cozy, family-friendly eatery on Sanibel Island, known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious, handcrafted pizzas. The casual setting, complete with outdoor seating, makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family. Beyond pizza, the menu also features fresh salads, hearty pasta dishes, and mouthwatering subs, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy. Don’t forget to bring a dollar bill with you—you’ll understand why when you step inside!
The Lighthouse Café
Though it took some time to rebuild, The Lighthouse Café is back and better than ever. Known as one of the best breakfast spots on the island, you can’t go wrong with their fluffy pancakes, omelets, or their famous “World’s Best” French toast. It’s a cozy, friendly spot that has retained its charm even after reopening.
Traders Sanibel
Traders is a beloved institution that’s returned with a fresh look and the same great food. The menu features a mix of seafood, steaks, and pasta, all with an island twist. Be sure to try their signature scallops or the coconut shrimp. The restaurant also offers live music, making it a lively spot for an evening out.
Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille
Doc Ford’s has managed to bounce back, reopening its doors and serving up the Caribbean-inspired dishes and craft cocktails it’s known for. The Yucatan shrimp and Beach Bread are a must-try, and the waterfront views are as stunning as ever. This spot is perfect for enjoying a relaxing meal while soaking in the island’s laid-back atmosphere.
Cielo
Cielo has reopened with a refined menu that continues to impress. This upscale dining spot offers Italian-inspired dishes with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. Whether you’re in the mood for house-made pasta, fresh seafood, or a perfectly cooked steak, Cielo delivers with elegance and flavor.
The Shack
The Shack on Sanibel is a beloved spot for those with a sweet tooth, offering some of the best frozen custard on the island. This charming, casual eatery specializes in creamy, delicious custard, served in a variety of flavors and topped with all your favorite toppings. Whether you’re in the mood for a tried-and-true classic or branching out to find a new favorite, The Shack delivers a refreshing treat that's perfect for cooling down on a warm day. With its beachy vibe and friendly service, it’s a must-visit for anyone looking to satisfy their dessert cravings while enjoying the laid-back island atmosphere.
______________
Sanibel Island’s culinary scene may have faced challenges, but the island’s spirit is as strong as ever. These restaurants represent both the resilience of the local community and the enduring appeal of Sanibel as a dining destination. Whether you’re looking for a casual bite or a fine dining experience, there’s something on the island for everyone. So come on down and enjoy a taste of Sanibel – you’ll be supporting local businesses and indulging in some truly memorable meals.
Need property management for your Sanibel home or condo. Check out our services here!